Best Restaurants in St. Augustine, FL
The Local Lion Food Fight is a live, locals-only leaderboard for the best restaurants in St. Augustine. Every category — burgers, pizza, tacos, coffee, seafood, brunch, date night, hidden gems, and more — is ranked by verified Roar and Meow votes from people who actually eat here. No paid placements. No tourist algorithm. Just neighbors.
Updated as verified votes come in
Current category winners in St. Augustine
The current #1 restaurant in every Local Lion Food Fight category, ranked by verified Roar Score.
- Best Burger in St. Augustine, FL
Current #1: The Ice Plant — West Augustine · 🦁 7 · 🐱 2
- Best Pizza in St. Augustine, FL
Current #1: Carmelo’s — Downtown · 🦁 8 · 🐱 0
- Best Tacos in St. Augustine, FL
Current #1: El Taco'n Madres · 🦁 9 · 🐱 1
- Best Coffee in St. Augustine, FL
Current #1: Ragga Surf Cafe · 🦁 1 · 🐱 0
- Best Breakfast in St. Augustine, FL
Current #1: Blue Hen Cafe — Lincolnville · 🦁 4 · 🐱 1
- Best Date Night Restaurants in St. Augustine, FL
Current #1: Catch 27 — Downtown · 🦁 2 · 🐱 0
- Best Seafood in St. Augustine, FL
Current #1: Schooner's Seafood — North · 🦁 3 · 🐱 0
- Best Brunch in St. Augustine, FL
Current #1: Blue Hen Cafe — Lincolnville · 🦁 1 · 🐱 0
- Best Hidden Gem Restaurants in St. Augustine, FL
Current #1: Blue Hen Cafe — Lincolnville · 🦁 3 · 🐱 0
- Most Overhyped Restaurants in St. Augustine, FL
Current #1: Pizzalley's — Downtown · 🦁 6 · 🐱 0
- Best Local Gatekept Restaurants in St. Augustine, FL
Current #1: Aunt Kate's — North Beach · 🦁 2 · 🐱 0
- Best Tourist Trap Restaurants in St. Augustine That Still Kinda Slap
Current #1: Sunset Grille — Anastasia · 🦁 3 · 🐱 2
- Best Shrimp Grits
No verified votes yet.
- Best Fish Dip
No verified votes yet.
- Best Datil Wings
No verified votes yet.
- Best Minorcan Clam Chowder
No verified votes yet.
- Best Conch Fritters
No verified votes yet.
- Best Blackened Fish Sandwich
No verified votes yet.
- Best Crab Cakes
No verified votes yet.
Top-roared restaurants in St. Augustine right now
The five restaurants with the most verified Roars across every Food Fight category.
- El Taco'n Madres — top spot in Best Tacos in St. Augustine, FL · 🦁 9 Roars
- Carmelo’s — top spot in Best Pizza in St. Augustine, FL · 🦁 8 Roars
- The Ice Plant — top spot in Best Burger in St. Augustine, FL · 🦁 7 Roars
- Pizzalley's — top spot in Most Overhyped Restaurants in St. Augustine, FL · 🦁 6 Roars
- Prohibition Kitchen — top spot in Best Burger in St. Augustine, FL · 🦁 6 Roars
Most controversial restaurants in St. Augustine right now
Spots where locals are roughly split between Roar and Meow — at least 10 verified votes and a Roar share between 35% and 65%.
- Prohibition Kitchen — split in Best Burger in St. Augustine, FL · 🦁 6 · 🐱 5
- Kaliburger — split in Best Burger in St. Augustine, FL · 🦁 5 · 🐱 5
How rankings work
Official rankings are based on verified Roar and Meow votes. Users can vote once per restaurant per category, and restaurants cannot pay to rank higher.
Frequently Asked
How are the best restaurants in St. Augustine ranked?
Rankings come from The Local Lion Food Fight — locals vote Roar if a spot deserves the hype or Meow if it's overhyped. Only verified votes count toward the official leaderboard.
Can restaurants pay to rank higher?
No. Official Food Fight rankings are based on verified local votes only.
Can I add a missing restaurant?
Yes. Use the "Add a Spot" button on any Food Fight category page. The Local Lion will review the submission before it joins the fight.
How often do rankings update?
Rankings update as verified votes come in. The leaderboards move in real time.