Best Pizza in St. Augustine, FL
Best Pizza — Roar if it slaps. Meow if the hype is criminal.
Trying to settle the pizza debate in St. Augustine? This Local Lion Food Fight leaderboard tracks the best pizza in town using verified local votes — no algorithms, no Yelp essays, just neighbors weighing in slice by slice.
The category most likely to ruin friendships.
You must be physically located in St. Johns County, FL to vote.
We verify your location to keep the Food Fight fair and local. If you're visiting or your location looks off, you can verify where you are after you vote.
Roar = worth it. Meow = overhyped.
🏆 Current Champions · Best Pizza
Top 3 of pizza spots
Carmelo’s
Downtown · Italian
🦁 “Voters are keeping it brief but bold, crowning Carmelo's as the top spot for a slice in the ancient city.”
Top 3 get featured here, on the homepage, and in the Roar Report newsletter.
Sign in with your email to vote. Old voters: use your same email and set a password — your past votes carry over.
📍 Voting is open to St. Johns County, FL only
- 🥇 1st · Gold
Carmelo’s
Downtown · Italian
🦁 17 Roars · 🐱 0 Meows · Score 17🦁 "Voters are keeping it brief but bold, crowning Carmelo's as the top spot for a slice in the ancient city."
Carmelo’s is listed in the Best Pizza Food Fight for St. Augustine locals to vote Roar or Meow. Website / Menu.
Own this business? Claim it here →
Tap now. Verify once to make it count.
- 🥈 2nd · Silver
Rosati’s Pizza
Saint Augustine
🦁 9 Roars · 🐱 0 Meows · Score 9🦁 "Rosatis holds the crown for authentic Chicago-style pies, with locals calling it the best deep dish and thin crust in the state."
Rosati’s Pizza is listed in the Best Pizza Food Fight for St. Augustine locals to vote Roar or Meow. Website / Menu.
Own this business? Claim it here →
Tap now. Verify once to make it count.
- 🥉 3rd · Bronze
Bronx House
Uptown · Pizza
🦁 5 Roars · 🐱 1 Meows · Score 4Bronx House is listed in the Best Pizza Food Fight for St. Augustine locals to vote Roar or Meow. Website / Menu.
Own this business? Claim it here →
Tap now. Verify once to make it count.
Alfred’s
West King
🦁 2 Roars · 🐱 0 Meows · Score 2Alfred’s is listed in the Best Pizza Food Fight for St. Augustine locals to vote Roar or Meow. Website / Menu.
Own this business? Claim it here →
Tap now. Verify once to make it count.
Vinny's Pizza
Vilano
🦁 1 Roars · 🐱 0 Meows · Score 1Vinny's Pizza is listed in the Best Pizza Food Fight for St. Augustine locals to vote Roar or Meow.
Own this business? Claim it here →
Tap now. Verify once to make it count.
Pizzalley's
Downtown
🦁 3 Roars · 🐱 2 Meows · Score 1Pizzalley's is listed in the Best Pizza Food Fight for St. Augustine locals to vote Roar or Meow. Website / Menu.
Own this business? Claim it here →
Tap now. Verify once to make it count.
Antonio’s
Beach
🦁 0 Roars · 🐱 0 Meows · Score 0Antonio’s is listed in the Best Pizza Food Fight for St. Augustine locals to vote Roar or Meow. Website / Menu.
Own this business? Claim it here →
Tap now. Verify once to make it count.
- 🦁 0 Roars · 🐱 0 Meows · Score 0
Five Star Pizza is listed in the Best Pizza Food Fight for St. Augustine locals to vote Roar or Meow.
Own this business? Claim it here →
Tap now. Verify once to make it count.
Amici Italian Restaurant
Anastasia · Italian
🦁 0 Roars · 🐱 0 Meows · Score 0Amici Italian Restaurant is listed in the Best Pizza Food Fight for St. Augustine locals to vote Roar or Meow. Website / Menu.
Own this business? Claim it here →
Tap now. Verify once to make it count.
Bella Vista
Fruit cove
🦁 0 Roars · 🐱 0 Meows · Score 0Bella Vista is listed in the Best Pizza Food Fight for St. Augustine locals to vote Roar or Meow. Website / Menu.
Own this business? Claim it here →
Tap now. Verify once to make it count.
St. Augie’s Pizza
Downtown
🦁 1 Roars · 🐱 1 Meows · Score 0🦁 "St. Augie's earns major points for its authentic New York style and welcoming family-owned atmosphere."
St. Augie’s Pizza is listed in the Best Pizza Food Fight for St. Augustine locals to vote Roar or Meow. Website / Menu.
Own this business? Claim it here →
Tap now. Verify once to make it count.
Vilano Grill 180
Vilano · American
🦁 1 Roars · 🐱 1 Meows · Score 0Vilano Grill 180 is listed in the Best Pizza Food Fight for St. Augustine locals to vote Roar or Meow.
Own this business? Claim it here →
Tap now. Verify once to make it count.
Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza
South · Italian
🦁 0 Roars · 🐱 1 Meows · Score -1Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza is listed in the Best Pizza Food Fight for St. Augustine locals to vote Roar or Meow. Website / Menu.
Own this business? Claim it here →
Tap now. Verify once to make it count.
Pizza Time
Downtown
🦁 0 Roars · 🐱 3 Meows · Score -3Pizza Time is listed in the Best Pizza Food Fight for St. Augustine locals to vote Roar or Meow. Website / Menu.
Own this business? Claim it here →
Tap now. Verify once to make it count.
How rankings work
Official rankings are based on verified Roar and Meow votes. Users can vote once per restaurant per category, and restaurants cannot pay to rank higher.
Frequently Asked
How are the best pizza spots in St. Augustine ranked?
Rankings on the pizza leaderboard are based on verified Food Fight votes from locals. Users can Roar if a spot deserves the hype, or Meow if they think it's overhyped.
Can restaurants pay to rank higher?
No. Official Food Fight rankings are based on verified votes only. There's no pay-to-play.
Can I add a missing restaurant?
Yes. Use the "Request a Spot" button on any category page. The Local Lion will review the submission before it joins the Food Fight.
How often do rankings update?
Rankings update as verified votes come in. The leaderboard moves in real time.