Carmelo’s
Italian · St. Augustine, FL · Downtown
Restaurant
Carmelo’s is in the Local Lion Food Fight — a live, vote-driven leaderboard of the best restaurants in St. Augustine. Locals Roar for spots worth the hype and Meow when something is overrated. Here's how Carmelo’s is doing right now.
🦁 18 Roars · 🐱 0 Meows · Score 18
Rankings are based on community votes. Paid plans do not affect leaderboard placement.
What voters say
"Voters are keeping it brief but bold, crowning Carmelo's as the top spot for a slice in the ancient city."
🦁 What they love
- Widely considered the best pizza in town
AI-summarized from 1 voter note
Where Carmelo’s Ranks
- Best Pizza in St. Augustine, FLRank #1 of 14
🦁 17 Roars · 🐱 0 Meows · Score 17
Vote in Best Pizza - Best Datil WingsRank #3 of 6
🦁 1 Roars · 🐱 0 Meows · Score 1
Vote in Best Datil Wings
About the Food Fight
The Local Lion Food Fight is a vote-driven ranking of the best restaurants in St. Augustine, FL. Rankings update as verified locals vote — no pay to play. Think Carmelo’s deserves more love? Roar for them in Best Pizza.