Carmelo’s
Italian · St. Augustine, FL · Downtown
Restaurant
Carmelo’s is in the Local Lion Food Fight — a live, vote-driven leaderboard of the best restaurants in St. Augustine. Locals Roar for spots worth the hype and Meow when something is overrated. Here's how Carmelo’s is doing right now.
🦁 19 Roars · 🐱 1 Meows · Score 18
Rankings are based on community votes. Paid plans do not affect leaderboard placement.
What voters say
"Carmelo's sparks a local debate, with some hailing it as the top pizza in town while others find the quality inconsistent."
🦁 What they love
- Strongly recommended by many as the best pizza in the city.
🐱 Not for everyone
- Some reports of undercooked dough and low-quality cheese.
- Occasional complaints that the price outpaces the quality.
AI-summarized from 2 voter notes
Where Carmelo’s Ranks
- Best Pizza in St. Augustine, FLRank #1 of 14
🦁 18 Roars · 🐱 1 Meows · Score 17
Vote in Best Pizza - Best Datil WingsRank #3 of 6
🦁 1 Roars · 🐱 0 Meows · Score 1
Vote in Best Datil Wings
About the Food Fight
The Local Lion Food Fight is a vote-driven ranking of the best restaurants in St. Augustine, FL. Rankings update as verified locals vote — no pay to play. Think Carmelo’s deserves more love? Roar for them in Best Pizza.